
The first concert I ever went to was Alanis Morissette in Seattle in 2000. Needless to say, her music had a huge impact on my teenage years and into my adult life. I never thought in a million years that my love for Alanis and my love for Broadway theater would collide.
The songs from the original album translate surprising well to the Jukebox Musical format. And, while the original album is not necessarily a “concept album” by itself, the original song lyrics required very little altering to fit together into a cohesive storyline. I guess credit for that goes to Diablo Cody’s ability to translate Alanis’ lyrics to a modern and relevant narrative.
Not only is every track from the original 1995 Album represented here on the Cast Recording, but additional tracks, mostly from her albums Supposed… and Under Rug Swept, as well as a couple new songs written for the musical, are included as well.
My favorite tracks:
Smiling
New song written for the musical. This song is haunting and on stage it all the character motions play out backwards, or in reverse time, and the result is chilling.
Perfect
Alanis’ music and lyrics being sung through a strong male voice hits me on a personal level. Props to Derek Klena for pulling off this solo ballad. It is fairly early in the show but it does not slow the show, nor does it bring the energy down.
That I Would Be Good
This song has been changed from a more linear one dimensional solo track to a polyphonic quartet(?) of sorts. This song comes from Alanis’ sophomore album Supposed Former Infatuation Junkie and is a decent, melancholy tune, but it really reaches out to new dimensions in this production.
Unprodigal Daughter
Catchy tune that keeps you on your toes. The bridge is especially delicious pop. Shout out to Alanis for including this random B-Side from her 3rd album Under Rug Swept. I know I wasn’t the only longtime Alanis fan thrilled to see this song on the album list. What a throw back!
One day I’ll saddle back and speak foreign adventures
One day I’ll double back and tell you about these unfettered years
One day I’ll look back and feel something other than relieved
Glad that I left when I did, I know you, you can’t get the best of me
And the kicker at the end:
I’d invite you but I’m busy being unoppressed
You Oughta Know
Lauren Patton earns her Tony Award for this tremendous performance. Full audience standing ovations are rare mid-performance, but this number received one when I saw it in New York in early 2020. Well deserved to say the least. This song is electrifying and the studio recording does not hold back.
You Learn
The finale is lovely and much more interesting than the original 1995 track. The original is good but it is very repetitive and all the background vocals are just Alanis’ own voice duplicated. The creativity here is taking a repetitive track and making it interesting for 5 minutes, which I feel that they have succeeded at. The harmonies are bright and vocals feel warm and strong. The inclusion of Thank U song melody and lyrics overlapping the last chorus is a nice touch.
In summary, it is such joy to see Alanis’ iconic album immortalized in the form of a Broadway musical. As Jukebox Musicals can be hit or miss, I feel that the creators did a great job showcasing the emotional power and complexities of the source material. Alanis really elevates the Jukebox musical experience by treating Jagged Little Pill as a concept album that can be expanded and built on, musically and lyrically. I look forward to see how the musical evolves in my lifetime.
Here is Lauren Patton mental-breakdown interpretive-dancing-to-find-God energy. Quality is not studio or pro, but you can feeeeeeeel it, man:
You can listen to the album here:
https://open.spotify.com/album/3JUvh3Ch6QFxguLABtTOE3?si=yJWmI_VXRJOnfMyvGwXOEA

