The 2011–12 Broadway season had so many gems, and was a mild relief to see such a diverse array of musicals following a couple years of slightly bland musical production. In this 2011-12 season, we were blessed with the successful Evita, Follies, Newsies, and Once. But also (still blessed) with the less successful Bonnie and Clyde, Ghost, and, the worlds worst titled musical and Not-Since-Carrie level flop, Spider-Man: Turn Off The Dark. Turn off the dark? What? Anyway, the amazing Audra McDonald and Norm Lewis bring fresh beautiful and modern life to the Gershwin opera Porgy and Bess. In the same 2011-12 season the Gershwin’s music was featured in another production, a revue titled Nice Work if You Can Get It.
Broadway productions of operas can present certain challenges, especially when trying to reach the low attention spanned tourists that frequent Broadway every year. We’ve seen successful productions of Puccini’s La Boheme, Bernstein’s Candide and West Side Story, among others, but for the most part, Broadway and Opera don’t always mix well with respect to business.
The new orchestrations and removal of recitations from Gershwin’s Porgy and Bess create a new musical landscape that respectfully reconceives the original Gershwin score into a Broadway score with dramatic underscores during dialogue, and boisterous, soulful, and lively renditions of the opera’s most famous numbers.
Stand Out tracks include Roll Them Bones/Summertime Reprise, Woman is a Sometime Thing, It Takes a Long Pull to Get There, the haunting Oh Doctor Jesus, I Got Plenty of Nothing, and the Act 1 and Act 2 Finales Oh I Can’t Sit Down and I’m On My Way, respectfully.
Audra McDonald’s performance is standout across the entire album, with Norm Lewis easily keeping up with the level of talent she brings.
Overall, I’d say they did a fantastic job turning the opera into a Broadway production. The casting was, obviously, spot on. This is one of my favorite recordings interpretations of this Gershwin classic. Here’s a great medley from the 2012 Tony Awards:









